SECTION 8 — Part 4

Evidence Index 

(A clear, investigator‑friendly map of all evidence referenced in Sections 1–7)

This index lists the documents, letters, notices, and communications that underpin the findings in this archive.

 

It allows investigators to cross‑reference dates, decisions, and contradictions without searching through the full bundle.

 

Migration & ESA Documentation

 

8 August 2025 — Migration Notice (Move from ESA to Universal Credit)

  • Mandatory notice requiring transition from income‑related ESA to UC by 9 November 2025.

ESA Arrears & Capital Disregard Letter (03/11/2023)

  • Confirms Severe Disability Premium arrears and permanent capital disregard.

ESA Reclassification Letter (29 January 2026)

  • First notification of ESA reclassification, four months after the change.

ESA Confirmation Letter (9 March 2026)

  • Confirms reclassification to contribution‑based ESA but provides no lawful decision notice.

Universal Credit Documentation

 

UC Appointment & Lost Evidence (September 2025)

  • Evidence submitted but not retained.

UC Capital Disregard Correction Letter (10 February 2026)

  • Confirms underpayment due to failure to apply capital disregard.

UC Monthly Statements (September 2025–January 2026)

  • Show ESA, SDA, and capital deductions.

 

Complaint Correspondence

 

28 January 2026 — UC Complaint Acknowledgement

  • Promises full response by 23 February.

10 February 2026 — Ministerial Route Acknowledgement

  • States response will be issued within 15 working days.

13 February 2026 — UC Complaint Update

  • Confirms investigation ongoing.

18 March 2026 — First Final Response

  • Sent to MP, not appointee.

31 March 2026 — Second Final Response

  • Received 7 April 2026; contradicts the first.

Parliamentary & ICE Correspondence

 

15 March 2026 — Parliamentary Escalation

  • Appointee requests MP intervention.

25 March 2026 — ICE Registration

  • ICE confirms complaint opened.

7 April 2026 — Appointee Submits Second Final Response to ICE

  • Adds second closure to case file.

9 April 2026 — ICE Confirmation

  • Confirms two closures, one duplicate case closed, investigation proceeding.

SECTION 9 — ATTACHMENTS LIST

(A clean list of all documents included in the bundle)

 

This section lists the attachments exactly as they appear in the archive, without reproducing their content.

 

ESA Documents

  1. ESA Arrears & Capital Disregard Letter (03/11/2023)
  2. ESA Reclassification Letter (29 January 2026)
  3. ESA Confirmation of ESA Award (9 March 2026)

UC Documents

  1. Migration Notice (8 August 2025)
  2. UC Capital Disregard Correction Letter (10 February 2026)
  3. UC Monthly Statements (Sept 2025–Jan 2026)

Complaint Handling

  1. UC Complaint Acknowledgement (28 January 2026)
  2. UC Complaint Update (13 February 2026)
  3. Ministerial Route Acknowledgement (10 February 2026)
  4. First Final Response (18 March 2026)
  5. Second Final Response (31 March 2026; received 7 April 2026)

ICE & Parliamentary

  1. Parliamentary Escalation Email (15 March 2026)
  2. ICE Registration Confirmation (25 March 2026)
  3. Appointee Submission to ICE (7 April 2026)
  4. ICE Confirmation Letter (9 April 2026)

SECTION 10

FINAL CURB NOTES FOR INVESTIGATORS

 

(A concise, respectful closing note addressed to investigators.

 Not adversarial, not emotional — just factual and steady)

 

This section is designed to help investigators understand the structure of the archive and the purpose of the submission.

 

It is not argumentative.

It is not accusatory.

It is a calm, professional framing statement.

 

Purpose of This Archive

 

This archive has been prepared to assist investigators in understanding the sequence of events, the procedural issues encountered, and the impact of administrative decisions on a vulnerable claimant and their appointee.

It is structured to:

  • present a clear chronology
  • identify contradictions
  • map procedural breaches
  • summarise safeguarding concerns
  • provide supporting evidence
  • ensure transparency and clarity

Scope of the Submission

 

This archive does not attempt to predict the outcome of the investigation.

It does not make legal assertions.

It does not assign intent.

It simply presents:

  • what happened
  • when it happened
  • what documents were issued
  • what was missing
  • what the consequences were

The purpose is to support a fair, thorough, and evidence‑based review.

 

Safeguarding Context

 

The claimant is a vulnerable adult with lifelong disabilities.

An appointee acts on their behalf.

Safeguarding considerations were raised repeatedly but not implemented.

 

This context is relevant to understanding the impact of delays, contradictions, and missing notices.

 

Complaint Handling Context

 

Two final responses were issued for one complaint.

 

This resulted in:

  • duplication
  • contradictory explanations
  • two separate complaint closures
  • ICE opening two cases

This archive provides the documentation needed to understand how this occurred.

 

Closing Note

 

The appointee has provided all available evidence and has no further information to add unless requested.

 

The family is willing to cooperate fully with any additional enquiries.

 

This archive is submitted in good faith, with the sole aim of ensuring clarity, accuracy, and safeguarding for a vulnerable claimant.

SECTION 11

CURRENT STATUS AND NEXT STEPS

(Public‑facing closing summary)

 

This update reflects the position as of 12 April 2026.

 

All evidence, correspondence, statutory notices, and final response letters have now been submitted to the Independent Case Examiner (ICE).

 

ICE has confirmed that:

  • the complaint is formally registered
  • one duplicate case was opened in error and closed
  • two separate final responses were issued by the Department
  • these constitute two complaint closures
  • both UC closures are now under investigation
  • no further action is required from the appointee at this stage

Although ESA did not issue a final response, ESA remains within the scope of ICE’s investigation. This is because both UC final responses attempted to explain ESA’s decisions, including the reclassification on 6 October 2025, the continuation of ESA payments into 2026, and the absence of statutory notices.

 

When a final response addresses issues relating to another part of the Department, ICE is empowered to examine those issues in full.

 

As the original complaint raised concerns about both ESA and UC, and UC’s final responses incorporated ESA matters, ICE will consider the actions, omissions, and procedural failures of both services as part of the overall investigation.

 

The process now is to await the outcome of ICE’s investigation.

 

If further issues arise before ICE concludes its review — including new correspondence, additional contradictions, or further procedural failures — these will be documented and added to the archive in a future update.

 

Once ICE has completed its investigation and issued its findings, the outcome will be added to this public‑facing forensic archive. Permission has been granted to publish the outcome in full.

 

This concludes the April 2026 update. The case remains active, and further developments will be added as new information, correspondence, or findings become available. The purpose of maintaining this ongoing record is to ensure clarity, transparency, and continuity as the investigation progresses, and to provide both public readers and investigators with an accurate account of each stage of the process.

 

CURB has also begun receiving new cases involving health‑service processes that raise similarly serious procedural and safeguarding concerns. These will be documented separately as the evidence is reviewed.

 

 

 

Design & Copyright Owner Maureen Booth-Martin (MBM) © All rights reserved

UA-54289644-1